Both options cover similar content. The difference is how a visitor moves through it. Below is a map of each, and a clickable low fidelity wireframe so you can see the shape before any design work starts. Everything here is grey on purpose. Colour, type, and photography come after the structure is agreed.
2 pages total. Everything on one scroll, with the menu on its own page.
4 pages total. Each one is a separate page with its own link.